Votes Summary

NDM4839 Plaid Cymru Debate - Motion without amendment
(2/11/11- 18:01:39)

Name

Political Party

Vote

Andrews, Leighton

Labour 

For

Sargeant, Carl

Labour 

For

Gregory, Janice

Labour 

For

Hutt, Jane

Labour 

For

Jones, Carwyn

Labour 

For

Hart, Edwina

Labour 

For

Lewis, Huw

Labour 

For

Griffiths, Lesley

Labour 

For

Griffiths, John

Labour 

For

Black, Peter

Liberal Democrat 

For

Williams, Kirsty

Liberal Democrat 

Did not vote

Davies, Jocelyn

Plaid Cymru 

For

Wyn Jones, Ieuan

Plaid Cymru 

For

Jones, Elin

Plaid Cymru 

For

Ffed Jones, Alun

Plaid Cymru 

For

Thomas, Gwenda

Labour 

For

Davies, Alun

Labour 

For

Cuthbert, Jeff

Labour 

For

Mewies, Sandy

Labour 

For

Hedges, Mike

Labour 

For

Chapman, Christine

Labour 

For

Davies, Keith

Labour 

For

James, Julie

Labour 

For

Ramsay, Nick

Conservative 

For

Millar, Darren

Conservative 

Did not vote

Graham, William

Conservative 

For

R T Davies, Andrew

Conservative 

For

Davies, Paul

Conservative 

For

Burns, Angela

Conservative 

For

Roberts, Aled

Liberal Democrat 

For

Parrott, Eluned

Liberal Democrat 

For

Powell, William

Liberal Democrat 

For

Glyn Thomas, Rhodri

Plaid Cymru 

For

Thomas, Simon

Plaid Cymru 

For

Wood, Leanne

Plaid Cymru 

For

Gruffydd, Llyr Huws

Plaid Cymru 

For

Jenkins, Bethan

Plaid Cymru 

For

Whittle, Lindsay

Plaid Cymru 

For

Elis Thomas, Dafydd

Plaid Cymru 

For

Rees, David

Labour 

For

Morgan, Julie

Labour 

For

Skates, Ken

Labour 

For

Antoniw, Mick

Labour 

For

Gething, Vaughan

Labour 

For

Watson, Joyce

Labour 

For

Jones, Ann

Labour 

For

Evans, Rebecca

Labour 

For

Neagle, Lynne

Labour 

For

Rathbone, Jenny

Labour 

For

Drakeford, Mark

Labour 

For

Price, Gwyn

Labour 

For

Asghar, Mohammad (Oscar)

Conservative 

For

Sandbach, Antoinette

Conservative 

For

George, Russell

Conservative 

For

Davies, Byron

Conservative 

For

Finch-Saunders, Janet

Conservative 

For

Davies, Suzy

Conservative 

For

Isherwood, Mark

Conservative 

For

 

For: 56
Abstain:  0
Against: 0

Total: 56

NDM4840 Welsh Liberal Democrats Debate - Motion without amendment
(2/11/11- 18:02:23)

Name

Political Party

Vote

Andrews, Leighton

Labour 

Against

Sargeant, Carl

Labour 

Against

Gregory, Janice

Labour 

Against

Hutt, Jane

Labour 

Against

Jones, Carwyn

Labour 

Against

Hart, Edwina

Labour 

Against

Lewis, Huw

Labour 

Against

Griffiths, Lesley

Labour 

Against

Griffiths, John

Labour 

Against

Black, Peter

Liberal Democrat 

For

Williams, Kirsty

Liberal Democrat 

Did not vote

Davies, Jocelyn

Plaid Cymru 

Against

Wyn Jones, Ieuan

Plaid Cymru 

Against

Jones, Elin

Plaid Cymru 

Against

Ffed Jones, Alun

Plaid Cymru 

Against

Thomas, Gwenda

Labour 

Against

Davies, Alun

Labour 

Against

Cuthbert, Jeff

Labour 

Against

Mewies, Sandy

Labour 

Against

Hedges, Mike

Labour 

Against

Chapman, Christine

Labour 

Against

Davies, Keith

Labour 

Against

James, Julie

Labour 

Against

Ramsay, Nick

Conservative 

For

Millar, Darren

Conservative 

Did not vote

Graham, William

Conservative 

For

R T Davies, Andrew

Conservative 

For

Davies, Paul

Conservative 

For

Burns, Angela

Conservative 

For

Roberts, Aled

Liberal Democrat 

For

Parrott, Eluned

Liberal Democrat 

For

Powell, William

Liberal Democrat 

For

Glyn Thomas, Rhodri

Plaid Cymru 

Against

Thomas, Simon

Plaid Cymru 

Against

Wood, Leanne

Plaid Cymru 

Against

Gruffydd, Llyr Huws

Plaid Cymru 

Against

Jenkins, Bethan

Plaid Cymru 

Against

Whittle, Lindsay

Plaid Cymru 

Against

Elis Thomas, Dafydd

Plaid Cymru 

Against

Rees, David

Labour 

Against

Morgan, Julie

Labour 

Against

Skates, Ken

Labour 

Against

Antoniw, Mick

Labour 

Against

Gething, Vaughan

Labour 

Against

Watson, Joyce

Labour 

Against

Jones, Ann

Labour 

Against

Evans, Rebecca

Labour 

Against

Neagle, Lynne

Labour 

Against

Rathbone, Jenny

Labour 

Against

Drakeford, Mark

Labour 

Against

Price, Gwyn

Labour 

Against

Asghar, Mohammad (Oscar)

Conservative 

For

Sandbach, Antoinette

Conservative 

For

George, Russell

Conservative 

For

Davies, Byron

Conservative 

For

Finch-Saunders, Janet

Conservative 

For

Davies, Suzy

Conservative 

For

Isherwood, Mark

Conservative 

For

 

For: 16
Abstain: 0
Against: 40

Total: 56

NDM4840 Amendment 1
(2/11/11- 18:02:54)

Name

Political Party

Vote

Andrews, Leighton

Labour 

For

Sargeant, Carl

Labour 

For

Gregory, Janice

Labour 

For

Hutt, Jane

Labour 

For

Jones, Carwyn

Labour 

For

Hart, Edwina

Labour 

For

Lewis, Huw

Labour 

For

Griffiths, Lesley

Labour 

For

Griffiths, John

Labour 

For

Black, Peter

Liberal Democrat 

Against

Williams, Kirsty

Liberal Democrat 

Did not vote

Davies, Jocelyn

Plaid Cymru 

For

Wyn Jones, Ieuan

Plaid Cymru 

For

Jones, Elin

Plaid Cymru 

For

Ffed Jones, Alun

Plaid Cymru 

For

Thomas, Gwenda

Labour 

For

Davies, Alun

Labour 

For

Cuthbert, Jeff

Labour 

For

Mewies, Sandy

Labour 

For

Hedges, Mike

Labour 

For

Chapman, Christine

Labour 

For

Davies, Keith

Labour 

For

James, Julie

Labour 

For

Ramsay, Nick

Conservative 

For

Millar, Darren

Conservative 

Did not vote

Graham, William

Conservative 

For

R T Davies, Andrew

Conservative 

For

Davies, Paul

Conservative 

For

Burns, Angela

Conservative 

For

Roberts, Aled

Liberal Democrat 

Against

Parrott, Eluned

Liberal Democrat 

Against

Powell, William

Liberal Democrat 

Against

Glyn Thomas, Rhodri

Plaid Cymru 

For

Thomas, Simon

Plaid Cymru 

For

Wood, Leanne

Plaid Cymru 

For

Gruffydd, Llyr Huws

Plaid Cymru 

For

Jenkins, Bethan

Plaid Cymru 

For

Whittle, Lindsay

Plaid Cymru 

For

Elis Thomas, Dafydd

Plaid Cymru 

For

Rees, David

Labour 

For

Morgan, Julie

Labour 

For

Skates, Ken

Labour 

For

Antoniw, Mick

Labour 

For

Gething, Vaughan

Labour 

For

Watson, Joyce

Labour 

Against

Jones, Ann

Labour 

For

Evans, Rebecca

Labour 

For

Neagle, Lynne

Labour 

For

Rathbone, Jenny

Labour 

For

Drakeford, Mark

Labour 

For

Price, Gwyn

Labour 

For

Asghar, Mohammad (Oscar)

Conservative 

For

Sandbach, Antoinette

Conservative 

For

George, Russell

Conservative 

For

Davies, Byron

Conservative 

For

Finch-Saunders, Janet

Conservative 

For

Davies, Suzy

Conservative 

For

Isherwood, Mark

Conservative 

For

 

For: 51
Abstain: 0
Against: 5

Total: 56

NDM4840 Amendment 2
(2/11/11- 18:03:16)

Name

Political Party

Vote

Andrews, Leighton

Labour 

Against

Sargeant, Carl

Labour 

Against

Gregory, Janice

Labour 

Against

Hutt, Jane

Labour 

Against

Jones, Carwyn

Labour 

Against

Hart, Edwina

Labour 

Against

Lewis, Huw

Labour 

Against

Griffiths, Lesley

Labour 

Against

Griffiths, John

Labour 

Against

Black, Peter

Liberal Democrat 

For

Williams, Kirsty

Liberal Democrat 

Did not vote

Davies, Jocelyn

Plaid Cymru 

For

Wyn Jones, Ieuan

Plaid Cymru 

For

Jones, Elin

Plaid Cymru 

For

Ffed Jones, Alun

Plaid Cymru 

For

Thomas, Gwenda

Labour 

Against

Davies, Alun

Labour 

Against

Cuthbert, Jeff

Labour 

Against

Mewies, Sandy

Labour 

Against

Hedges, Mike

Labour 

Against

Chapman, Christine

Labour 

Against

Davies, Keith

Labour 

Against

James, Julie

Labour 

Against

Ramsay, Nick

Conservative 

For

Millar, Darren

Conservative 

Did not vote

Graham, William

Conservative 

For

R T Davies, Andrew

Conservative 

For

Davies, Paul

Conservative 

For

Burns, Angela

Conservative 

For

Roberts, Aled

Liberal Democrat 

For

Parrott, Eluned

Liberal Democrat 

For

Powell, William

Liberal Democrat 

For

Glyn Thomas, Rhodri

Plaid Cymru 

For

Thomas, Simon

Plaid Cymru 

For

Wood, Leanne

Plaid Cymru 

For

Gruffydd, Llyr Huws

Plaid Cymru 

For

Jenkins, Bethan

Plaid Cymru 

For

Whittle, Lindsay

Plaid Cymru 

For

Elis Thomas, Dafydd

Plaid Cymru 

For

Rees, David

Labour 

Against

Morgan, Julie

Labour 

Against

Skates, Ken

Labour 

Against

Antoniw, Mick

Labour 

Against

Gething, Vaughan

Labour 

Against

Watson, Joyce

Labour 

Against

Jones, Ann

Labour 

Against

Evans, Rebecca

Labour 

Against

Neagle, Lynne

Labour 

Against

Rathbone, Jenny

Labour 

Against

Drakeford, Mark

Labour 

Against

Price, Gwyn

Labour 

Against

Asghar, Mohammad (Oscar)

Conservative 

For

Sandbach, Antoinette

Conservative 

For

George, Russell

Conservative 

For

Davies, Byron

Conservative 

For

Finch-Saunders, Janet

Conservative 

For

Davies, Suzy

Conservative 

For

Isherwood, Mark

Conservative 

For

 

For: 27
Abstain: 0
Against: 29

Total: 56

NDM4840 Amendment 3
(2/11/11- 18:03:44)

Name

Political Party

Vote

Andrews, Leighton

Labour 

For

Sargeant, Carl

Labour 

For

Gregory, Janice

Labour 

For

Hutt, Jane

Labour 

For

Jones, Carwyn

Labour 

For

Hart, Edwina

Labour 

For

Lewis, Huw

Labour 

For

Griffiths, Lesley

Labour 

For

Griffiths, John

Labour 

For

Black, Peter

Liberal Democrat 

For

Williams, Kirsty

Liberal Democrat 

Did not vote

Davies, Jocelyn

Plaid Cymru 

For

Wyn Jones, Ieuan

Plaid Cymru 

For

Jones, Elin

Plaid Cymru 

For

Ffed Jones, Alun

Plaid Cymru 

For

Thomas, Gwenda

Labour 

For

Davies, Alun

Labour 

For

Cuthbert, Jeff

Labour 

For

Mewies, Sandy

Labour 

For

Hedges, Mike

Labour 

For

Chapman, Christine

Labour 

For

Davies, Keith

Labour 

For

James, Julie

Labour 

For

Ramsay, Nick

Conservative 

For

Millar, Darren

Conservative 

Did not vote

Graham, William

Conservative 

For

R T Davies, Andrew

Conservative 

For

Davies, Paul

Conservative 

For

Burns, Angela

Conservative 

For

Roberts, Aled

Liberal Democrat 

For

Parrott, Eluned

Liberal Democrat 

For

Powell, William

Liberal Democrat 

For

Glyn Thomas, Rhodri

Plaid Cymru 

For

Thomas, Simon

Plaid Cymru 

For

Wood, Leanne

Plaid Cymru 

For

Gruffydd, Llyr Huws

Plaid Cymru 

For

Jenkins, Bethan

Plaid Cymru 

For

Whittle, Lindsay

Plaid Cymru 

For

Elis Thomas, Dafydd

Plaid Cymru 

For

Rees, David

Labour 

For

Morgan, Julie

Labour 

For

Skates, Ken

Labour 

For

Antoniw, Mick

Labour 

For

Gething, Vaughan

Labour 

For

Watson, Joyce

Labour 

For

Jones, Ann

Labour 

For

Evans, Rebecca

Labour 

For

Neagle, Lynne

Labour 

For

Rathbone, Jenny

Labour 

For

Drakeford, Mark

Labour 

For

Price, Gwyn

Labour 

For

Asghar, Mohammad (Oscar)

Conservative 

For

Sandbach, Antoinette

Conservative 

For

George, Russell

Conservative 

For

Davies, Byron

Conservative 

For

Finch-Saunders, Janet

Conservative 

For

Davies, Suzy

Conservative 

For

Isherwood, Mark

Conservative 

For

 

For: 56
Abstain: 0
Against: 0

Total: 56

NDM4840 Amendment 4
(2/11/11- 18:04:02)

Name

Political Party

Vote

Andrews, Leighton

Labour 

For

Sargeant, Carl

Labour 

For

Gregory, Janice

Labour 

For

Hutt, Jane

Labour 

For

Jones, Carwyn

Labour 

For

Hart, Edwina

Labour 

For

Lewis, Huw

Labour 

For

Griffiths, Lesley

Labour 

For

Griffiths, John

Labour 

For

Black, Peter

Liberal Democrat 

For

Williams, Kirsty

Liberal Democrat 

Did not vote

Davies, Jocelyn

Plaid Cymru 

For

Wyn Jones, Ieuan

Plaid Cymru 

For

Jones, Elin

Plaid Cymru 

For

Ffed Jones, Alun

Plaid Cymru 

For

Thomas, Gwenda

Labour 

For

Davies, Alun

Labour 

For

Cuthbert, Jeff

Labour 

For

Mewies, Sandy

Labour 

For

Hedges, Mike

Labour 

For

Chapman, Christine

Labour 

For

Davies, Keith

Labour 

For

James, Julie

Labour 

For

Ramsay, Nick

Conservative 

For

Millar, Darren

Conservative 

Did not vote

Graham, William

Conservative 

For

R T Davies, Andrew

Conservative 

For

Davies, Paul

Conservative 

For

Burns, Angela

Conservative 

For

Roberts, Aled

Liberal Democrat 

For

Parrott, Eluned

Liberal Democrat 

For

Powell, William

Liberal Democrat 

For

Glyn Thomas, Rhodri

Plaid Cymru 

For

Thomas, Simon

Plaid Cymru 

For

Wood, Leanne

Plaid Cymru 

For

Gruffydd, Llyr Huws

Plaid Cymru 

For

Jenkins, Bethan

Plaid Cymru 

For

Whittle, Lindsay

Plaid Cymru 

For

Elis Thomas, Dafydd

Plaid Cymru 

For

Rees, David

Labour 

For

Morgan, Julie

Labour 

For

Skates, Ken

Labour 

For

Antoniw, Mick

Labour 

For

Gething, Vaughan

Labour 

For

Watson, Joyce

Labour 

For

Jones, Ann

Labour 

For

Evans, Rebecca

Labour 

For

Neagle, Lynne

Labour 

For

Rathbone, Jenny

Labour 

For

Drakeford, Mark

Labour 

For

Price, Gwyn

Labour 

For

Asghar, Mohammad (Oscar)

Conservative 

For

Sandbach, Antoinette

Conservative 

For

George, Russell

Conservative 

For

Davies, Byron

Conservative 

For

Finch-Saunders, Janet

Conservative 

For

Davies, Suzy

Conservative 

For

Isherwood, Mark

Conservative 

For

 

For: 56
Abstain: 0
Against: 0

Total: 56

NDM4840 Welsh Liberal Democrats Debate - Motion as amended
(2/11/11- 18:04:17)

Name

Political Party

Vote

Andrews, Leighton

Labour 

Against

Sargeant, Carl

Labour 

Against

Gregory, Janice

Labour 

Against

Hutt, Jane

Labour 

Against

Jones, Carwyn

Labour 

Against

Hart, Edwina

Labour 

Against

Lewis, Huw

Labour 

Against

Griffiths, Lesley

Labour 

Against

Griffiths, John

Labour 

Against

Black, Peter

Liberal Democrat 

For

Williams, Kirsty

Liberal Democrat 

Did not vote

Davies, Jocelyn

Plaid Cymru 

For

Wyn Jones, Ieuan

Plaid Cymru 

For

Jones, Elin

Plaid Cymru 

For

Ffed Jones, Alun

Plaid Cymru 

For

Thomas, Gwenda

Labour 

Against

Davies, Alun

Labour 

Against

Cuthbert, Jeff

Labour 

Against

Mewies, Sandy

Labour 

Against

Hedges, Mike

Labour 

Against

Chapman, Christine

Labour 

Against

Davies, Keith

Labour 

Against

James, Julie

Labour 

Against

Ramsay, Nick

Conservative 

For

Millar, Darren

Conservative 

Did not vote

Graham, William

Conservative 

For

R T Davies, Andrew

Conservative 

For

Davies, Paul

Conservative 

For

Burns, Angela

Conservative 

For

Roberts, Aled

Liberal Democrat 

For

Parrott, Eluned

Liberal Democrat 

For

Powell, William

Liberal Democrat 

For

Glyn Thomas, Rhodri

Plaid Cymru 

For

Thomas, Simon

Plaid Cymru 

For

Wood, Leanne

Plaid Cymru 

For

Gruffydd, Llyr Huws

Plaid Cymru 

For

Jenkins, Bethan

Plaid Cymru 

For

Whittle, Lindsay

Plaid Cymru 

For

Elis Thomas, Dafydd

Plaid Cymru 

For

Rees, David

Labour 

Against

Morgan, Julie

Labour 

Against

Skates, Ken

Labour 

Against

Antoniw, Mick

Labour 

Against

Gething, Vaughan

Labour 

Against

Watson, Joyce

Labour 

Against

Jones, Ann

Labour 

Against

Evans, Rebecca

Labour 

Against

Neagle, Lynne

Labour 

Against

Rathbone, Jenny

Labour 

Against

Drakeford, Mark

Labour 

Against

Price, Gwyn

Labour 

Against

Asghar, Mohammad (Oscar)

Conservative 

For

Sandbach, Antoinette

Conservative 

For

George, Russell

Conservative 

For

Davies, Byron

Conservative 

For

Finch-Saunders, Janet

Conservative 

For

Davies, Suzy

Conservative 

For

Isherwood, Mark

Conservative 

For

 

For: 27
Abstain: 0
Against: 29

Total: 56